Folweb Studios

A Rule for the Square

A lamp at a tree and a second lamp beyond the stall line
A lamp at a tree and a second lamp beyond the stall line

The first custom in The Unlit Procession concerns a lamp near an oak. A villager says the lamp stays dark until the procession crosses the square. The investigator hears the rule while there is still light in the sky. Another witness remembers a flame behind the stalls. This test is about the difference between a custom, the parts of it people observed and what the two statements can support together.

Show the custom in an ordinary action

On a first pass, one stall holder carries a lamp to the edge of the path and leaves it on a low stone. The action needs an ordinary reason to occur where it does. The stone is beside the place where people collect before they enter the road. The player can see the movement and a handful of other preparations from the square. That establishes part of the custom without a speech explaining every detail of the festival.

A villager can later explain why people leave the lamp there. Keep the explanation tied to the lamp beside the tree and the time before the procession. Do not use a general rule about all lamps everywhere in the village if the later case depends on a particular one. A familiar custom can have a place and time, and a name that does not apply to every similar object. These distinctions are the material the player needs to investigate.

Move the second witness around the corner

The next witness can see a house behind the stalls. Their account describes a lit lamp on a table there. The investigator can ask whether the witness saw it carried to the oak. In one opening, they did not. The statement still helps locate another preparation in the village. The same testimony loses value if the interface automatically makes it evidence that the lamp beside the oak was lit.

Put the source and place next to each statement so they can be read together. The first prototype can compare a short sentence showing the place with a small map that connects each witness to their visible area. Use the same dialogs in both. A reader who understands the difference should be able to point to a pair of statements that do not really contradict one another.

Test one genuine exception separately

After the first visit, place a villager at the oak who saw someone alter its lamp. This is a more direct observation of the object itself. Record it as a different kind of account and give the player time to follow up. The custom still explains why the alteration matters. The game does not need to dismiss the rule when the exception is introduced, and the player does not need to treat a new claim as fully verified.

Ask the player to distinguish between a witnessed departure from a custom and a remembered event at a different location. If they use the words of the last witness for both, improve the way the journal retains the source. Once the line is readable, change one earlier detail and repeat. The goal is to learn what context someone needs before choosing a next question, rather than to measure whether they reached a fixed answer.

Collect the unresolved parts

Finish the test with a note containing what the investigator actually saw, what someone reported and which part of the custom each line applies to. The same structure can carry a question that has no answer yet. See Two Views of One Stall for a second look at the witness positions. What the Oak Kept uses the distinction when two objects become linked in a rumor.